Cases – Some Active Cases – Johnny Lee Gates

JOHNNY LEE GATES

Conviction Factors

Official Misconduct

False Confession

Race Discrimination

Ineffective Counsel

Flawed Eyewitness ID

Incentivized Informant

Charges

Armed Robbery
Rape
Murder

Muscogee

County

1977

Conviction

Death

Sentence

43+

Years Served

CO-COUNSEL:     Southern Center for Human Rights

                             Muscogee County, Georgia

Muscogee County, GA | November 30, 1976

On November 30, 1976, a young woman's husband found her murdered in their apartment. Soon thereafter, a white man was seen fondling the victim's body in the funeral home. The man then confessed to murdering the young woman, and reportedly appeared to know facts about the case that only the perpetrator could have known. But, at the prosecutor’s urging, a grand jury did not indict.

The case appeared to have gone cold when, months later, a man arrested on criminal charges tried to win favor from the police department by conveying that he had information about the unsolved murder that had stumped the department for months. The incentivized informant told police that Johnny Lee Gates – a young black man with an intellectual disability – had raped, shot and killed the young woman, then threw the gun into a creek. By the time police realized their informant had lied and the gun in the creek was not the murder weapon, Johnny had already given a false confession. The resulting inaccurate confession was later described by a judge as “hard to believe."

The highest rates of false confessions occur among the intellectually disabled, juveniles, and the mentally ill. These individuals are often vulnerable to the pressures of coercive police interrogation techniques because they are less likely to understand the charges against them and the consequences of confessing. Astonishingly more than 1 out of 4 people wrongfully convicted but later exonerated by DNA evidence made a false confession or incriminating statement.

After Columbus police secured a written confession from Johnny, they escorted him to the crime scene and had him walk throughout the crime and repeat his confession on videotape. Despite having thoroughly searched the crime scene two months earlier and locating no fingerprints matching Gates, and despite securing a written confession before taking Gates to the crime scene, police waited until immediately after they escorted Gates through the crime scene to dust a specific area of the apartment for prints. The state then introduced those fingerprints at trial as evidence that Johnny had committed the crime months prior.

That fingerprint evidence, a flawed and inconsistent eyewitness identification, and Johnny’s confessions, formed the basis of the jury's conviction and death sentence, which was handed down after an alarmingly short trial where the defense attorney did not call a single witness. The jury never heard about the first confession of the man fondling the victim’s body, or that police found a large smear of Type B blood near the victim even though the victim and Gates were Type O. They never heard that the semen on the victim’s robe was Type B, or the reasons the eyewitness identification was flawed. Additionally, the prosecuting attorneys in Gates' 1977 trial struck all qualified black jurors, ensuring that his case would be heard by an all-white jury - a systematic practice that they repeated in several death penalty trials of black defendants in the late 1970’s.

The State destroyed the vast majority of evidence in Mr. Gates' case less than two years after trial. But in 2015, GIP interns located a tie and a belt used to forcefully bind the victim. Those items were DNA tested and determined to be exculpatory.

Johnny Lee Gates never received his constitutional right to a fair trial, and he has been in prison for 43 years for a crime he did not commit. GIP and SCHR have asked a Muscogee County Superior Court judge to find that Johnny was wrongfully convicted, and to grant him a new trial.

Update: March 13, 2020

Georgia Supreme Court Affirms Order Granting New Trial for Johnny Lee Gates.

Loader Loading...
EAD Logo Taking too long?

Reload Reload document
| Open Open in new tab

Download

Update: January 10, 2019

Muscogee County Superior Court Judge John Allen orders new trial for Johnny Lee Gates based on new exculpatory DNA evidence. Finds profound and undeniable race discrimination by DA’s office in selection of all white juries in death penalty trials in 1970’s and 1980’s. Read the decision below:

Loader Loading...
EAD Logo Taking too long?

Reload Reload document
| Open Open in new tab

UPDATES

/ News

Georgia inmate freed after 43 years for crime he denies committing

Georgia inmate freed after 43 years for crime he denies committing Outlet: Atlanta Journal-Constitution Author: Bill Rankin Published: 5/15/2020 Read: ...
/ News

Judge Rejects Plea Deal for Man Convicted in 1976 Slaying

Judge Rejects Plea Deal for Man Convicted in 1976 Slaying Outlet: New York Times Author: The Associate Press Published: 5/12/2020 ...
/ News

Columbus murder suspect granted new trial could walk free after 43 years in prison

Columbus murder suspect granted new trial could walk free after 43 years in prison Outlet: Ledger-Enquirer Author: Tim Chitwood Published: ...
/ Case Update

Georgia Supreme Court Rules in Favor of GIP Client Johnny Lee Gates!

Georgia Supreme Court Rules in Favor of GIP Client Johnny Lee Gates! Johnny Lee Gates has spent 43 years imprisoned ...
/ News

Georgia’s High Court Rules DNA Evidence Warrants New Trial

Georgia’s High Court Rules DNA Evidence Warrants New Trial Outlet: New York Times Author: The Associated Press Published: 3/13/2020 Read: ...
/ News

Inmate granted new trial in 1976 rape, murder of 19-year-old Columbus woman

Inmate granted new trial in 1976 rape, murder of 19-year-old Columbus woman Outlet: Atlanta Journal-Constitution Author: Shaddi Abusaid Published: 3/13/2020 ...
/ News

After death sentence and 43 years in prison, Columbus man will get new trial in murder case

After death sentence and 43 years in prison, Columbus man will get new trial in murder case Outlet: Ledger-Enquirer Author: ...
/ News

Georgia’s high court rules DNA evidence warrants new trial

Georgia’s high court rules DNA evidence warrants new trial Outlet: Associated Press Author: RUSS BYNUM Published: 3/13/2020 Read: Here ...
/ News

Lawyers debate DNA evidence in convicted Columbus killer’s case at Georgia Supreme Court

Lawyers debate DNA evidence in convicted Columbus killer’s case at Georgia Supreme Court Outlet: Columbus Ledger-EnquirerAuthor: Joe Kovac Jr.Published: 8/20/2019Read: ...
/ News

All-white Jury, DNA Evidence may get convicted Georgia man new trial after 42 years

All-white Jury, DNA Evidence may get convicted Georgia man new trial after 42 years Outlet: Columbus Ledger-Enquirer Author: Tim Chitwood ...