Sonny Bharadia

Chatham County, GA | November 18, 2001

In 2001, a woman walked in on a man who was in the process of burglarizing her home in Thunderbolt, Georgia. The man sexually assaulted the woman at knife-point and then fled with some of her belongings. Before the woman was assaulted, she noticed that the man was wearing blue and white batting gloves.

Sonny Bharadia was in Lithonia, Georgia, over 250 miles away from Thunderbolt, working on a friend’s car during the time the victim was attacked. 

Just a few days after the assault occurred, Sonny called police to report that Sterling Flint, an acquaintance of Sonny’s, had stolen Sonny’s car and was also in possession of a stolen motorcycle. In response, Sterling Flint threatened to kill Sonny, which Sonny also reported to the police.

When police went to investigate Sterling, they discovered the sexual assault victim’s stolen property along with a pair of blue and white batting gloves. When the victim was shown a photo lineup, she identified Sterling Flint as her possible attacker.

When police directly connected Sterling to the sexual assault, Sterling tried to deny his involvement by claiming that the stolen items found among his personal possessions actually belonged to Sonny Bharadia. After Sterling attempted to shift the blame to Sonny, police then gave the victim a second photo lineup that did not include Sterling and, this time, she identified Sonny Bharadia as her possible attacker. Sterling, a Black man, and Sonny, an Indian man, look nothing alike. 

While we have never seen this photo array, Sonny’s former attorney remembers laughing with the former police chief about how suggestive the array was, claiming that Sonny’s picture “jumps off the page at you.” (The state never disclosed either of these photo arrays to Sonny’s attorney, which meant he could not use the fact that the victim also identified Sterling Flint in a photo array in Sonny’s favor at trial.)

The DA charged both Sonny and Sterling in this crime. Sterling pleaded guilty to receiving the victim’s stolen property and, in exchange for not being prosecuted for a sex crime, testified against Sonny Bharadia. No physical evidence tied Sonny to the crime. Sterling’s incentivized testimony, along with the victim’s revised eyewitness identification, were the only evidence supporting the prosecution’s case against Sonny.

On June 27th, 2003, Sonny Bharadia was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. 

At the time of trial, the batting gloves worn by the attacker were not tested for DNA evidence because the technology to do so did not yet exist. However, several years later, when Georgia Innocence Project took on Sonny’s case, DNA testing technology had advanced to the point that “touch” DNA testing could be performed on the gloves. Using DNA from skin cells left on the gloves, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation was able to extract a DNA profile and compare it with a sample obtained from Sonny. The DNA didn’t match. It did, however, match someone else: Sterling Flint.

Sonny Bharadia Exonerated — May 16, 2025

After Sonny’s conviction was overturned, the case was sent back to the Chatham County District Attorney’s Office to determine whether they would continue to prosecute Sonny. Noah Pines of Ross & Pines, LLC, joined Sonny’s legal team for re-trial proceedings. While awaiting the State’s decision on prosecution, Sonny was granted bond and released from custody.

On May 16, 2025, Sonny was fully exonerated when the State chose to dismiss the case against him. After fighting his wrongful conviction for almost 22 years, Sonny was finally vindicated in his quest to prove his innocence.

Pictured: GIP Senior Attorney Christina Cribbs, former GIP Staff Attorney Olivia Vigiletti (co-counsel), Sonny Bharadia, and Noah Pines of Ross & Pines (co-counsel).