Time Lost: 8189 days 13 hours 29 minutes 58 seconds
Floyd County, GA | January 11, 2000
At 7:19 pm on January 11, 2000, Rome-Floyd County 911 dispatched an ambulance to the scene of a single-vehicle accident on Hwy 27, which runs between Rome and Cedartown, GA. The driver, 21-year-old Isaac Dawkins, was rushed to the hospital. X-rays would later reveal that Isaac had been shot in the head while he was driving; he died shortly thereafter. Police initially identified Joey Watkins as a suspect, since Joey had admittedly driven past the wreck scene that night, and Joey and Isaac both previously had argued over a girl named Brianne that they each dated on separate occasions. After conducting an investigation, the Rome Police Department eventually ruled Joey out as a suspect.
After months with little progress on the case, the victim’s family successfully petitioned to have Sergeant Stanley Sutton of the Floyd County Police Department take over the case. Although a very similar shooting had occurred a few miles away, and within minutes of when police first received reports of Isaac’s accident, and although Joey had an alibi, Sutton zeroed in on Joey Watkins. One day after taking over the case, the Floyd County Police Department posted $10,000 reward posters throughout the jail; the first jailhouse informant came forward within hours.
Twelve months after the crime, the State charged Joey and his friend, Mark Free, with Isaac’s murder. There were glaring issues with the State’s theory. One issue was that the man who witnessed the accident explained to police that he saw a small, older-model blue car interacting aggressively on the road with Isaac’s truck in the moments before the wreck. The night of the murder, however, Joey had driven his white pickup truck to see his girlfriend, Aislinn, who lived about 30 miles away in Cedartown, Georgia (he passed Isaac’s wreck and police cars on the way). He was seen by several witnesses departing in his white truck, and approximately 45 minutes later, several other witnesses saw him in Cedartown in his white truck.
The victim's pickup truck that tailed off the side of the highway following the murder.
Although Joey had been seen leaving home in his pickup truck, the State theorized that he met up with his friend Mark Free, switched from his white truck to the small, blue Honda, drove down to around Floyd College to either wait for or intercept Isaac as he drove home from college, engaged in aggressive driving with Dawkins, and then shot Dawkins through the back window of Dawkins’ truck while driving at 55+ miles per hour (and talking on the phone to his girlfriend Aislinn). According to the State, Joey then switched cars again and drove to his girlfriend’s house in Cedartown, where he arrived in his white truck. According to the State, Joey accomplished all of this in 45 minutes–the amount of time it would take him to drive straight from his house to his girlfriend’s house in Cedartown.
There was another major problem with the State’s theory. It is undisputed that Joey was using his cell phone in the time frame before, during, and after the crime. Cell phone and cell tower records, and expert testimony, placed him miles from the scene of the crime at the time of the shooting.
Despite all the problems with the State’s theory, Joey Watkins was sentenced to life in prison plus six years on July 2nd, 2001.
Eventually, Joey Watkins wrote to GIP and we began investigating his case. In 2016, the popular true-crime podcast Undisclosed also took an interest in Joey’s case and undertook an extensive investigation in conjunction with GIP, culminating in the discovery of new factual information establishing that Joey Watkins’ constitutional rights were violated. As a result of GIP and Undisclosed’s findings, GIP and co-counsel Ben Goldberg filed a habeas petition in early 2017 arguing that Joey should be released from prison because of recently discovered juror misconduct and official misconduct (the State’s concealment of exculpatory evidence and presentation of false or misleading evidence at trial).
In 2018, at a hearing on the procedural viability of Joey Watkins’ claims, Walker County Judge Don Thompson dismissed Joey’s habeas petition at the State’s request, finding that Joey was too late to bring his claims and that he could not bring them in a second habeas petition.
GIP asked the Georgia Supreme Court to let us appeal and to correct Judge Thompson’s erroneous order.
After reconsidering their initial decision denying our request, the Georgia Supreme Court heard our appeal and decided the case was improperly dismissed.
In its opinion, linked here, the Court concluded that “Watkins has alleged facts showing grounds for relief which could not reasonably have been raised in his original habeas petition and which could not have been discovered by the reasonable exercise of due diligence.”
The Court reversed the dismissal of Joey’s petition and remanded the case to the habeas court, where Joey would finally be able to present the merits of his petition on juror misconduct and official misconduct.
After years of litigation and a three-day hearing in February/March 2022 where Joey’s legal team presented evidence supporting claims that Joey’s constitutional rights were violated, Walker County Superior Court Judge Don Thompson GRANTED Joey Watkins' Habeas Corpus Petition on April 11th, 2022. Judge Thompson’s order overturned Joey’s conviction and granted him a new trial.
The State (Georgia’s Attorney General) must decide by May 11, 2022, whether to appeal Judge Thompson’s decision to the Georgia Supreme Court. If they appeal, it likely will take many months before the high court will hear arguments and issue an opinion. We are exploring options to get Joey released from custody while his case is still pending.
If the Attorney General does not appeal, then Joey’s conviction remains officially overturned. However, the original charges will still be pending absent action by the Floyd County District Attorney’s Office, meaning that Joey would still be facing murder charges. It will be up to the local district attorney to decide whether to dismiss the charges (exonerating Joey), negotiate a plea deal, or take the case to trial again.
You can hear Joey’s story on the second season of the Undisclosed podcast.
Possession of a Firearm
Life + 6